Paperwork first

Three in four big EU online shops we could check link to an accessibility page. Two in three of those sites still fail a basic check.

13 November 2026 · Peculiar Systems

On 7 November, three weeks before Black Friday, we pointed our accessibility scanner at 100 of the most-visited online shops in ten EU countries. The European Accessibility Act has covered online shops since 28 June 2025.

Three in four of the shops we could check link to a page about their accessibility. The page did not make the site work. Of the 44 sites with such a page that our scanner could read, 28 failed at least one basic check, such as an image with no text alternative. Without the page, 16 of 17 failed.

So far, the only accessibility breach regulators have fined is missing paperwork.

Sample · 100 shops

Who let us in

The countries are Germany, Austria, France, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands, Poland, Czechia, Sweden and Denmark. For each we took Similarweb's public top-five lists for September 2026 in four categories: marketplaces, fashion, consumer electronics, and home and garden. That gives 20 places per country. We went through them in rounds, every list's number one, then every number two, and kept the first 10 consumer shops. Classifieds sites like Vinted and OLX, sites that are not shops, and repeats of a brand were skipped. Similarweb ranks sites by visits, not by revenue. The list of shops is open.

Not every shop let us in. On 76 of the 100 we could check whether the home page links to an accessibility page. The rest met us with a captcha or a security page, or put the accessibility page behind one. On 65 our scanner could read the pages. 61 shops are in both groups, and the comparison below uses those.

Paperwork · 76 shops

The page

57 of the 76 shops link from the home page to a page explaining how people with disabilities can use the site. We opened every link, and each leads to such a page. 19 shops have no link.

The site · 65 shops

What a screen reader hears

On one shop's home page, a "See all" link is followed by 11 or more links with no name. From the page's code, a screen reader would announce "See all" and then just "link", again and again. Where each one goes, the listener has to guess.

Our scanner read each shop's home page and the category and product pages it could reach. It ran axe-core and our own tests for keyboard use and zoom. We counted six basic checks, and 48 of the 65 shops failed at least one.

32 shops had text with too little contrast, 28 had links without a name, and 26 had images without a text alternative. 41 had at least one link, button, form field or image that a screen reader cannot name. On 24 home pages the content needed sideways scrolling at 320 pixels wide, which is what 400% zoom looks like on a 1280-pixel screen.

Page or no page · 61 shops

Better, still failing

Shops with an accessibility page did better than shops without one, but most still failed.

FAILS AT LEAST ONE BASIC CHECKLinks an accessibility page28 of 44No link16 of 17
The 61 shops where we could check both; 17 is a small group. 4 more were scanned, but their accessibility link led behind a captcha.

The results are open, one row per shop, without the shop's name. Every number in this note can be counted from that file.

Enforcement · Czechia, France

What gets fined

The Czech trade inspectorate has issued 15 fines under the accessibility law, from about €40 to about €1,000. All 15 together come to about €4,500.

Each cites the same rule: the shop's terms did not explain how its service is accessible, as the Czech law requires. In 13 of the 15, the same fine also covers other breaches found in the inspection, mostly under consumer law, so only part of the €4,500 is for accessibility. The law asks for this information in the terms, not on the home page, so a missing link is not a breach by itself.

No regulator in the EU has yet fined a shop because its site fails with a screen reader. The one decision about a site itself came from a court. On 4 June a judge in Caen ordered Carrefour to make its website and app accessible, or pay €500 a day, starting six months after the ruling. That is 4 December, a week after Black Friday.

What follows

The shop behind the paperwork

Shops did the paperwork first, and regulators fined the paperwork first. The barriers we found are in the shop itself: on the home, category and product pages where people browse before they buy.

An accessibility page describes a site. Before the busiest week of the year, test the site it describes.


Checked 13 November 2026: every source and number in this note re-checked on that day. Shops scanned on 7 November from our server; accessibility links checked the same day from a second network. Automated checks find some barriers, not all, and we did not test any shop by hand, so this is neither an audit nor a compliance verdict. That is why the list of shops is open but the results carry no names; journalists can ask for them per shop at contact@peculiar.systems. The Czech fines, as listed in the EAA Sanctions Register on 6 November, are CZK 1,000 to CZK 25,000 and CZK 110,000 in total, all citing § 14(1) of Act 424/2023, 13 of them together with other laws; euros at the ECB rate of 13 November, CZK 24.424 per euro. Shop owners can run the same first check on their own site with ShopOffen, free and without an email address.